($50, Laurent-Perrier USA): I was pleasantly surprised to find this Champagne still selling at the retail level at Garnet Wines and Liquors in Manhattan because most Champagnes from the excellent 2002 vintage have disappeared. It has the hallmark elegance of Laurent Perrier, a suave creaminess and lovely freshness despite 10 years of age.… Read more
Category Archives: Reviews
Guigal, Condrieu (Rhône Valley, France) 2010
($57, Vintus): Condrieu, home to Viognier grape, can be a hard wine to get right. Viognier needs to be ripe to express its floral character, but not so ripe that the alcohol shows. Guigal hit the bulls eye with their 2010. … Read more
Bruno Paillard, Champagne Grand Cru (France) Blanc de Blancs “Réserve Privée” Brut NV
($100, Vintus): The grapes for this bottling come exclusively from four grand cru villages in the Côte des Blancs, the area within the Champagne region known for Chardonnay. One taste explains why many people swoon over a Blanc de Blancs Champagne. … Read more
Daniel Chotard, Sancerre (Loire Valley, France) 2010
($25): The problem with Sancerre over the last two or three decades has been its popularity, both in the bistros of Paris and on these shores. The result has been a dilution of quality with many examples tasting more like Sauvignon Blanc and less like Sancerre. … Read more
Guigal, Côtes du Rhône Blanc (Rhône Valley, France) 2010
($18, Vintus): Wine lovers know Guigal is one of the top, if not the top, producers of red wines in the Rhône Valley. Their red Côte du Rhône is a consistent winner. Their white Côte du Rhone has been getting better and better as they’ve increased the proportion of Viognier in the blend. … Read more
Disznókõ, Tokaj (Hungary) Aszú 5 Puttonyos 2005
($45, Vintus): Tokaj is one of the world’s great places for producing sweet wines. To produce a sweet wine, winemakers there add over-ripe and shriveled grapes (Aszú) that may or may not have been attacked by botrytis or “noble rot” to the juice just before fermentation. … Read more
Domaine du Gros’Noré, Bandol Blanc (Provence, France) 2009
($30, Kermit Lynch): Bandol, a small appellation bordering the Mediterranean, is well known for its sturdy Mourvedre-based red wines. But growers also make a tiny amount of white wine from the usual Mediterranean varieties, Bourboulenc, Clairette, and Ugni Blanc, as well as Sauvignon Blanc. … Read more
Domaine des Baumard, Savennières (Loire Valley, France) 2008
($24): Savennières, a tiny appellation on the Loire River, makes unique dry and racy wines from Chenin Blanc, a grape better known for sweet wines. Baumard is one of the appellation’s leading producers. Baumard’s 2008, bottled under screw cap to preserve freshness, has an alluring combination of honey-like, but not sweet, richness and savory, sharp, che 91 Michael Apstein May 22, 2012… Read more
Domaine des Baumard, Savennières (Loire Valley, France) Clos du Papillon 2008
($38): As good as Baumard’s regular bottling of Savennières is, this one, from a particularly well-sited vineyard, is even better. With more complexity, the interplay of richness and savory herbal notes in the Clos du Papillon creates even more intrigue. Despite the increased concentration, this maintains impeccable balance and finesse.… Read more
Domaine des Baumard, Quarts de Chaume (Loire Valley, France) 2008
($70, Vintus): Quarts de Chaume, a tiny appellation in the Loire Valley, is capable of producing extraordinary sweet wines from the Chenin Blanc grape. Florent Baumard believes that the hallmark of the 2008 vintage is an uplifting acidity in the wines. … Read more
Guigal, St. Joseph (Rhône Valley, France) “Vignes de l’ Hospice” 2007
($145, Vintus): Hermitage and St. Joseph have precisely the same soil because when the Rhône River turned south, it sliced through the granite hill instead of coursing around it, putting Hermitage on the eastern bank and St. Joseph on its western bank. … Read more
Guigal, Gigondas (Rhône Valley, France) 2007
($32, Vintus): To my mind, Guigal is a genius. And this wine shows why. Gigondas is usually a big burly wine reflective of its home in the rugged area of the southern Rhone. With concentrated black fruit-like flavors sprinkled with black pepper notes, Guigal’s 2007 Gigondas certainly has the burly aspect covered. … Read more
Château Recougne, Bordeaux Supérieur (Bordeaux, France) 2009
($16, Vintus): As always, this “simple” Bordeaux is satisfying and a great value. The herbal nuances that accompany the mixture of fruit flavors are what make it so appealing. It has the length and grace you’d expect from a more expensive bottling. … Read more
Guigal, Côte-Rôtie (Rhône Valley, France) “Brune et Blonde” 2007
($72, Vintus): The Brune et Blonde designation indicates that the wine comes from grapes grown in a variety of parcels on the two major slopes of the appellation, the Côte Brune and the Côte Blonde, names that reflect the color of the soil. … Read more
Disznókõ, Tokaji (Hungary) Dry Furmint 2011
($20, Vintus): Although Tokaji is renown for its delectable sweet wine, the region also makes dry wine from the same grape, Furmint. This one is clean and fresh with a slightly steely signature that makes it extremely appealing with grilled fish and roast chicken.… Read more
Guigal, Crozes Hermitage (Rhone Valley, France) 2007
($24): Not surprisingly given the appellation, Guigal’s 2007 Crozes-Hermitage is more distinctive than his Côtes du Rhone. It conveys attractive black pepper notes and a ripe dark-fruit character reflective of the warm 2007 vintage. It has added depth along with the hallmark Guigal classiness. … Read more
Guigal, Cotes du Rhone (France) 2007
($18): Guigal is the finest producer in the Rhone, making tiny quantities of iconic, single-vineyard, expensive (hundreds of dollars a bottle) Côte Rôtie, elegant Condrieu, and stunning Hermitage. I could go on and on. He also makes hundreds of thousands of cases of affordable red Côtes du Rhone. … Read more
Telmo Rodriguez, Rioja (Spain) “LZ” 2010
($16): Telmo Rodriguez always thinks outside of the box. He eschews the conventional Rioja classification of Crianza, Reserva and Gran Reserva, which refers to the amount of aging the wine receives before release. Rather, he prefers to highlight the site, the origin of the grapes, in this case from the village of Lanciega.… Read more
Erazzuriz, Aconcagua Valley (Chile) “Kai” 2008
($158): Errazuriz thinks outside of the box. While much of the Chilean industry was focusing on basic $10 Cabernet and Merlot, Errazuriz, led by Eduardo Chadwick, was heading in a different direction. Make no mistake, Errazuriz does make excellent basic Cabernet and Merlot. … Read more
Telmo Rodriguez, Valdeorras (Spain) Mencia “Gaba do Xil” 2010
($18): Valdeorras, the valley of gold, named because the Romans discovered the metal there, is nestled in the northwestern part of Spain. The Mencia grape, usually associated with Bierzo, the adjacent DO, also does well in the region. The beauty of wine made from Mencia, like this one, is the earthy, savory (non-fruit) nuances it delivers along with the charming combination of red fruit flavors. … Read more
Domaine Humbert Frères, Gevrey-Chambertin (Burgundy, France) Vieilles Vignes 2009
($60, Vins Divins): Not all village wines are created equal, which highlights another flaw in the French appellation system. This one towers above most village wines because of the contribution of the old vines that, for whatever reason, add a dose of complexity. … Read more
Château Tour D’Auron, Bordeaux Supérieur (Bordeaux, France) 2009
($16, Vintus Imports): Château Tour D’Auron is a château controlled by the well-regarded and talented Milhade family, who produces a bevy of fine wines from all their properties. This “little” wine exemplifies why Bordeaux is so popular. Supple and polished, it has the concentration of the 2009 vintage. … Read more
Dog Point, Marlborough (New Zealand) Pinot Noir 2008
($39, Vintus): The Marlborough region of New Zealand is best known for their vibrant and zesty Sauvignon Blanc. It’s clear from this Pinot Noir that Marlborough has more to offer. (Dog Point does also make splendid Marlborough Sauvignon Blanc). Their Pinot Noir is bright and fresh. … Read more
Errazuriz, Aconcagua Valley (Chile) Carménère “Max Reserva” Estate Single Vineyard 2010
($21, Vintus): Carménère is Chile’s signature grape. Originally grown in Bordeaux, it was mostly abandoned there because it was such a late ripening variety. Initially in Chile it was confused with Merlot and harvested early with Merlot, which imparted an unpleasant greenness to the wine. … Read more
Mas Belles Eaux, Languedoc (France) “Les Coteaux” 2008
($20, Vintus): AXA, the insurance company that also owns Château Pichon Baron and other superb properties, purchased this one in 2002 because it had “good bones.” They poured gobs of money into it renovating and modernizing the vineyards and winery and it shows in this gorgeous wine. … Read more
Cave de Tain, St. Joseph Rouge (Rhône Valley, France) “Esprit de Granite” 2009
($22, Cognac One): The appellation of St. Joseph lies on the right (West) bank of the Rhône, facing east and its more famous neighbor, Hermitage. Though the granite soil is similar to that of Hermitage and the grape (Syrah) is the same, the wines are lighter and earlier maturing because the east-facing exposure means less sunlight–and ripeness–during the harvest season. … Read more
Mommessin, Clos de Tart (Burgundy, France) 2009
($485, Jeanne-Marie de Champs, Domaines & Saveurs Collection): Clos de Tart is one of the most under rated grand crus of the Côte de Nuits. Located in Morey St. Denis and owned entirely by the Mommessin family, it has been producing sensational wine since Sylvain Pitiot, who is obsessed with quality, took over as cellar master in 1996. … Read more
Domaine Philippe Faury, St. Joseph Blanc (Rhône Valley, France) 2009
($27, Winebow): St. Joseph, well known for its reds, also produces a small amount (less than 10% of the appellation) of white wine from the usual white grapes of the Rhône, Marsanne and Roussanne. In this one, the substantial amount of Roussanne (40%), imparts freshness and verve to the fruitier and slightly lanolin-like textured Marsanne. … Read more
Cave de Tain, Saint-Péray (Rhône Valley, France) “Fleur de Roc” 2009
($20, Cognac One): Saint-Péray, a tiny appellation in the Rhône, produces only white or sparkling wine. Cave de Tain is the local, highly regarded cooperative there. Like many Rhône white wines, this one delivers fleshy yellow fruit flavors. But unlike many white Rhônes, it also has lovely brightness and vivacity to balance the usual waxy texture. … Read more
Vidal-Fleury, Côtes du Rhône Blanc (Rhône Valley, France) 2010
($17, W. J. Deutsch & Sons Ltd.): This is a brilliant white Côtes du Rhône. Guigal, the leader in the Rhône, purchased Vidal-Fleury about twenty-five years ago. Their hand, in the form of a healthy amount of Viognier, is apparent in this wine. … Read more
Vidal-Fleury, St. Joseph Rouge (Rhône Valley, France) 2007
($30, W. J. Deutsch & Sons Ltd.): Although owned by Guigal, the Rhône’s leading producer, since the mid-1980s, Vidal-Fleury remains a separate commercial entity with a separate winemaking team. Nonetheless, the elegance and grace for which Guigal is known shows in this wine. … Read more
Reviews: FRANCE – Burgundy
Dupont-Tisserandot, Gevrey-Chambertin 1er Cru (Burgundy, France) Lavaux St. Jacques 2006 ($96, VOS Selections): This premier cru comes across a little coarser than his Les Cazetiers and shows Burgundy’s earthier side. Although not as refined, it conveys a charming rusticity. It would be a good choice for more robust fare.… Read more
Alain Burguet, Gevrey-Chambertin (Burgundy, France) “Mes Favorites” Vieilles Vignes 2009
($100, Frederick Wildman): Here’s an example of how the French appellation system breaks down. This village wine delivers more elegance and complexity than many producers’ wines from premier cru vineyards. For this wine, Burguet combines grapes from old vines located in various parcels that lie on the slope between the village and the road. … Read more
Casa Lapostolle, Rapel Valley (Chile) Carménère “Casa” 2010
($12, Moët Hennessey USA): Founded in part by the Marnier Lapostolle family (of Grand Marnier fame) Casa Lapostolle was one of the early Franco-Chilean endeavors. They remain one of Chile’s leading producers. They produce at least three tiers of wine, with their “Casa” label falling the in middle. … Read more
Potel-Aviron, Julienas (Beaujolais, Burgundy, France) 2010
($15): As with the rest of Burgundy, Beaujolais had two great back-to-back vintages in 2009 and 2010. And, as with the rest of Burgundy, the styles of the two vintages in Beaujolais are very different, making it extremely difficult to choose between the two. … Read more
Potel-Aviron, Beaujolais Villages (Beaujolais, Burgundy, France) 2009
($16, Frederick Wildman): Stéphane Aviron describes his 2009 Beaujolais as “sunny wines” because of the warmth of the vintage. Anyone who thinks that all Beaujolais is just tutti-fruity and jammy should try his wines. Spiced with a touch of minerality, this 2009 Beaujolais Villages harbors not a hint of overt grapey flavors. … Read more
Domaine Dominique Gallois, Gevrey-Chambertin 1er Cru (Burgundy, France) Les Petits Cazetiers 2009
($90, Frederick Wildman): Les Petits Cazetiers is adjacent to Les Cazetiers, its famous neighbor that many producers believe is the village’s best premier cru vineyard. But there’s nothing small about this wine. It’s quintessential Burgundy delivering flavor without heaviness. Leathery and earthy notes peek out from a rich, but not overbearing, assortment of red and black fruit flavors. … Read more
Numanthia, Toro (Castilla y León, Spain) “Termanthia 2007
($225, Moët Hennessey USA): Wines trying to achieve “greatness” by relying on power alone fail because they lack elegance. Power will get a wine noticed, but it is not the component that determines the wine’s quality. Numanthia’s Termanthia, their top of the line wine made from vines that are over 100 years old, succeeds because it delivers great concentration while retaining elegance.… Read more
Casa Lapostolle, Colchagua Valley (Chile) Clos Apalta 2008
($75, Moët Hennessey USA): This, Casa Lapostolle’s top wine, remains one of Chile’s best. Made primarily from Carménère, Chile’s signature grape, it combines fruit flavors—both black and red—with earthy and herbal notes in a luxuriously supple package of fine tannins. The non-fruit nuances for which Carménère is notorious add great complexity. … Read more
Potel-Aviron, Côte de Brouilly (Beaujolais, Burgundy, France) Vieilles Vignes 2009
($18, Frederick Wildman): The Côte de Brouilly, one of the ten crus of Beaujolais, is known for stylish wines. And this is one of them. Firm, but not hard, a classy minerality explodes on the palate. This is serious stuff. 92 Michael Apstein Mar 27, 2012… Read more
Chateau de Sancerre, Sancerre (Loire Valley, France) 2010
($22, Moët Hennessey USA): I love authentic Sancerre, such as this one, because it transmits an earthy chalky edginess, along with the grapefruity side of Sauvignon Blanc. The 2010 Chateau de Sancerre has length and body, elements often lacking in modern Sancerre. … Read more
Cheval des Andes, Mendoza (Argentina) 2007
($73, Moët Hennessey USA): The result of a joint project between Chateau Cheval Blanc in St. Emilion and Argentina’s Terrazas de los Andes, the Cheval des Andes erases any idea that Argentina cannot produce great wines. The winemaking team led by Nicolas Audebert has put together a marvelous combination of dark fruit and mineral-like flavors all wrapped in velvety-like tannins. … Read more
Maison Louis Jadot, Beaune Premier Cru (Burgundy, France) Clos des Couchereaux 2009
($40, Kobrand): There should be no question about the quality of the 2009 vintage for red Burgundy. A potential criticism is that they lack structure that would allow them to develop complexity with age. Well, one sip of this wine dispels that notion. … Read more
Craggy Range, Martinborough (New Zealand) Sauvignon Blanc Te Muna Road Vineyard 2011
($20, Kobrand): Although the Marlborough region on the north tip of the South Island has made a name for itself for stunning Sauvignon Blanc—and rightly so—Martinborough, just a stone’s throw away on the southern tip of the North Island, also is home to stylish Sauvignon Blanc, especially in Craggy Range’s hands. … Read more
Chateau Ste. Michelle, Columbia Valley (Washington) Gewurztraminer 2010
($9): What’s so remarkable about Château Ste. Michelle, Washington’s largest producer, is their ability to make terrific inexpensive as well as stunning high-end wines. This bargain-priced Gewürztraminer delivers spiced fruit-flavors (gewürz means spicy), cutting citrus acidity and a whiff of sweetness that amplifies the wine’s spicy side. … Read more
Numanthia, Toro (Castilla y León, Spain) “Termes” 2008
($30, Moët Hennessey USA): Toro, like so many other Spanish appellations, is undergoing a renaissance led, in no small measure, by Numanthia. (The winery takes its name from the nearby town of Numancia). They make three wines, Termanthia, Numanthia (which leads to the perseverating Numanthia’s Numanthia) and this one, Termes, distinguished chiefly by the age of the vines. … Read more
Cape Mentelle, Margaret River (Western Australia, Australia) Sauvignon Blanc/Semillon 2011
($17, Moët Hennessey USA): I’m always surprised that the SBS (as they’re known in Australia) wines aren’t as popular here as they are down under. Cape Mentelle, one of Western Australia’s leading producers, made a particularly alluring one in 2011. Its creamy luxurious side–Semillon speaking–is offset and balanced by a pleasant tang from the Sauvignon Blanc. … Read more
Cloudy Bay, Marlborough (New Zealand) Late Harvest Riesling 2008
($31, Moët Hennessey USA): Cloudy Bay put New Zealand on the world’s wine map with their Sauvignon Blanc two decades ago. They just might do the same with Late Harvest Riesling, judging from this one. Sure, it’s sweet, but not cloying, and delivers hints of peaches and apricot skin. … Read more
Cloudy Bay, Marlborough (New Zealand) Sauvignon Blanc 2011
($31, Moët Hennessey USA): You might think that Cloudy Bay would rest on its laurels given their tremendous reputation at producing exemplary Sauvignon Blanc. But they haven’t. They’ve actually increased the quality of their all ready terrific Sauvignon Blanc as the vines age and they gain even more experience with their vineyards. … Read more
Cloudy Bay, Marlborough (New Zealand) Pinot Noir 2009
($40, Moët Hennessey USA): Marlborough is usually ranked after Central Otago and Martinborough when considering prime sites for Pinot Noir in New Zealand. A few more wines like this one and that paradigm in likely to change. Sarah Burton and the winemaking team has managed to capture both the fruity and savory sides of Pinot Noir in their 2009 bottling. … Read more